Intro
This essay will be answering the question ‘Is the merchant of Venice an anti-semetic play?.’ Anti-Semetism is racism or discrimination towards Jews. There are a lot of examples of this in the play. One example of this is in the beginning of the play Shylock gets spat on by a Christian named Antonio. The Merchant of Venice has a lot of tension between Christians and Jews. This is because back in 1596 Jews were known to be money lenders and not a part of society. They were seen as an outcast. To answer this question thoroughly I will be sharing my,Shakespeare’s and Jonathan Freeland’s (2004) point of view. Using the play and the evidence from the history of Jews in 1596, I will try and answer this question. The first paragraph will be talking about Jonathan Freeland’s (2004) point of view.
Paragraph One
Jonathan Freeland (2004) thinks that the Merchant of Venice is an anti-semetic play. He says that Shakespeare portrays Shylock (the Jew) as a villain. In the beginning of the play a Jew gets spat on. This already shows some anti-semitism in the Merchant of Venice.The reason why he thinks this is because in his article called ‘A very Jewish villain’ he says that in the play Shakespeare makes Shylock look like a selfish man. He says that Shakespeare shows this by making Shylock cry about his riches being lost and not his daughter.
Paragraph Two
We know this because in the play he says ‘My daughter! O my ducats! O my daughter’ Jonathan Freeland says one way how Shakespeare makes Shylock look selfish is because his first words are ‘Three thousand ducats'(this was what the money was called back then.) When Shylock signs a contract with Antonio saying if he does not pay him back in three months he will take a pound of Antonio’s flesh. Freeland says that this is meant to stir the memories of when Jews took Christian blood for Jewish rituals. He says that Shakespeare is clearly trying to use anti-Semitism here. He also says that Shakespeare does this to try and make people laugh. This shows Anti-Semitism because Shakespeare is trying to make Jews look bad and say that they are not very good people. If this message gets across to the audience then other people could change their mind about the Jewish religion. Then the person may not talk to Jews. This is another reason stating that the Merchant of Venice is anti-semetic.
Paragraph Three
Another way to see that the play is anti semetic is that when Shylock wants to take his bond on Antonio, the court says that what he is doing is not right when they buy flesh theirselves. This is another example of antisemetism in the play. I personally think that the play is antisemetic at times because in the play Shakespeare makes Shylock talk about money a lot. By doing this he is trying to make Shylock selfish. Another reason why I think this play is antisemetic is because Christians are seen as these people that need to be treated better than Jews, which is not true because in the bible it says everybody should be treated equally. This means everybody should be respected in the same way. Shakespeare thought that by making an antisemetic play he would make people laugh, which he did but it also made people such as Jews offended. This is not right, which is why I respect Jonathan Freeland(2004) for writing an article defending his religion.
Paragraph Four
I personally think that Shakespeare doesn’t care what he’s done because in the end he got what he wanted, which was for people to laugh at his antisemetic play. Maybe if people stood up and said they didn’t like what he was doing like how Jonathan Freeland was doing then he would feel guilty. I reckon people did still feel angry but they didn’t talk because everybody would think they were crazy. Anti-Semitism was a normal thing when Shakespeare was around so everybody was cool with Shakespeare making anti-Semitic plays. Shakespeare knew that by doing this he would get a positive reaction from the majority of people that watch the play. He obviously didn’t care about offending Jews or anyone else.
Conclusion
To conclude this essay I will leave you with this. The Merchant of Venice is an Anti-semetic play, or at least thats what I think. The author of this play, Shakespeare clearly wanted a reaction which is what he got. We cannot change the past but we can change the future. So instead of dwelling on the fact that the play is anti-semetic and Shakespeare is to blame for it, make plays and movies that embrace the fact that everybody should be treated the same. The merchant of venice is only a mistake that we can use to make the world a better place.
Continue reading
Recent Comments